I think what we've got here is one of those movies that was "underrated" for so long that it became slightly overrated.
When Hot Rod first came out, it was trashed by critics, as SNL alum movies often are. But then, over the following years, it slowly found its audience, and now it feels like the praise has gone a bit overboard - particularly on Reddit. Seriously, go to any thread with a prompt like "What's a hated movie that you love?", and the top answers are almost always Grandma's Boy, Hook, and this.
I wouldn't go so far, personally. The tone and storytelling are pretty inconsistent, the Napoleon Dynamite presentation only occasionally works, and I've just never been huge on Lonely Island's brand of quirky and meta comedy. But I won't pretend that I didn't also have fun with it, and audibly laugh at some of the dumb and entirely unnecessary antics (with the two big standouts being Rod falling down that giant hill for close to a minute and the motivational montage suddenly turning into a violent riot).
Plus, as ridiculous as this movie often gets, there's also a sincerity to it that provides some emotional grounding. We laugh at Rod more than we laugh with him, but we still want to see the guy succeed, and that kind of rooting interest makes the humour and the characters a lot more likeable as a result.
Grade: B
And, with that, the first hundred is officially out of the way. Only 9,900 to go!






